Design and Art - Is It Expressive?


The arguments put forward in the debate between Micah Bowers and Miklos Philips are great. They succinctly cover the fundamental differences and similarities between art and design, and provide interesting viewpoints on what those fundamentals mean regarding the relationship between the two disciplines. 
Despite the comprehensive nature of their discussion, one can’t help but feel they have focused too much on themes of form/function, objectivity/subjectivity, and problem/solution. These are all very valid points which do well to describe the execution of art and design, however these subjects do not address why a designer or artist embarks on such an endeavour in the first place. 
As a graphic designer, when I produce a piece of work, there is usually someone ordering it from me (and hopefully compensating me with money or services). The same can often be said of art. Whether it’s a renaissance painter who has been ordered by a king to paint a relief on a cathedral, or a modern-day installation artist responding to the demands of a curator, artists (like designers) often produce their work with the aim of pleasing a client, audience, critic, etc. 
So what happens if there is no financial or career-enhancing incentive? Is that what truly separates art from design, when someone expresses themselves for some other reason?
You could say so. Someone may draw a picture to vent their anger, write a song to win over a lover, act on stage to overcome their anxiety. These forms of creative expression certainly seem more artistic than someone creating a magazine layout or drawing icons.
In the overly-commodified art world of today, it is easy to lose sight of these forms of true expression, and the value they have. However at the same time, many people disregard creative expression in design and architecture due to the fact that there is a client and that money is involved. Just because it is not personal does not mean it is not expressive. It is true that at the end of the day the client’s word is final. However within the confines of deliverables, target audiences, tone, content and so on, a designer can find lots of room to be creative, and indeed sometimes even express their own emotions and opinions (if they align with those of the client). 
The key to this concept is that there are varying degrees of creative freedom within both art and design, depending on a myriad of factors. True, the circumstances surrounding the artistic process often place less constraints on an artist’s creative expression than those of a designer, however this is not always the case, especially if a designer feels passionately about what they are working on, and have a like-minded client / team.
One could say that the obstacles to straightforward expression cause designers to develop a different and more versatile type of creativity, with less emphasis on expression and more on reaching the desired solution. This hypothesis allows us to return safely to the well-defined arguments put forward by Mr. Bowers and Mr. Phillips, instead of worrying about creative expression and all that intangible stuff. 

Comments